As if immigrant rights groups needed another reason to distrust the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials have cleared its agents of any wrongdoing in a recent internal investigation made due to reports of abuse. Earlier this year, ICE sparked controversy when federal agents allegedly followed immigrant parents to and from a Detroit elementary school as they dropped off their children, trapping the parents inside the school. After residents, advocates and state officials accused ICE of violating their own enforcement policies, ICE director John Morton, along with other officials, promised to investigate the matter. Instead of demanding a thorough investigation, the results of their attempt for an investigation have left local community groups outraged and fearful of whether ICE is capable of holding itself accountable in the future.
This highly publicized case of ICE misconduct occurred last April when six ICE agents allegedly followed immigrant parents inside the Hope of Detroit Academy, trapped them inside for nearly an hour and later arrested at least two parents “in warrantless stops” outside the school. The Alliance of Immigrant Rights and Reform Michigan (AIR) accused ICE of violating their own enforcement policies which prohibit intimidation tactics near schools or places of worship, and said ICE’s actions followed a “pattern of abuse,” namely “warrantless searches, detainees being denied medicines and the harassment of American citizens.” As a result of the community protesting, ICE director John Morton said the agency would launch an investigation into the accusations and take appropriate steps pending a review. The final report of the incident, however, recently given by ICE’s Office of Professional Responsibility, found that ICE agents did not “violate an agency policy against enforcement at sensitive locations because it took place blocks away from the school.” These findings left local immigration groups furious, a clip of the response made by the Alliance for Immigrant Rights Director, Ryan Bates, follows:
“We believe that the ICE report was a complete whitewash that shows that the Dept. of Homeland Security and ICE in particular is unable to police itself.” ICE failed to interview witnesses and victims, took officers at their word when they said they had followed policy, and never addressed the issue of whether officers had warrants for searches they conducted. I find it insulting that ICE claims no enforcement action happened there.”
Even Detroit Rep. John Conyers said he had some serious concerns with ICE’s review. Lawrence Garcia, president of the Michigan Hispanic Bar Association, also found the agency’s findings troubling:
“They admit that they were at the school and they were conducting enforcement activities. What they deny is that the activity was violative of the policy at the time. If they stake out a sensitive location but they complete the detention at a location so many feet or blocks away they say that didn’t violate the policy as it used to exist.”
As things stand now, it is clear that the results of ICE’s internal investigation have left many fearful that ICE is incapable of monitoring itself against potential abuse and misconduct. Given the recent controversy surrounding ICE’s Secure Communities program, the agency’s credibility is on the line, but even more important still is that of the safety and security of the communities ICE claims to be protecting.